10 WESTHOLME, HUTTON RUDBY, YARM TS15 OEA

EMAIL: clerk@rudbyparishcouncil.gov.uk   TEL:  07384 415440

13th October 2026

Openreach Pole Objections Team

Floor 2, The Plaza

100 Old Hall Street

Liverpool

Merseyside

L3 9QJ

Dear Sir,

RE:  Proposed Installation of Eight Wooden Poles on The Village Green at Hutton Rudby

BT Site Notice References:

H0J-V22001 (5 off Notices Dated 22/9/26)

Description of proposed installationwhat3words location reference
11m light wood pole opp 11 North Side TS15 0DA +deal.mirror.worlds
11m light wood pole opp 21 North Side TS15 0DAtinted.unfilled.heavy
11m light wood pole o/s 1 2 3 North End, TS15 0DGholiday.dislikes.else
11m light wood pole opp 31 32 33 South Side TS15 0DFdrape.taxi.emulated
11m light wood pole opp 33 North Side TS15 0DAconveying.reinvest.headless

+ Reference number is unclear on the notice for this location, but it is assumed to be the same as the others with the same date.

HOJ-V9040 (3 off Notices Dated 24/9/26)

Description of proposed installationwhat3words location reference
11m light wood pole opp 2 South Sidecobble.comet.equipping
10m light wood pole o/s 14 East Sidereadjust.codes.handbook
12m medium wood pole, opposite Wheatsheaffired.tonality.slugs

Rudby Parish Council writes as the landowner of the Registered Village Greens in Hutton Rudby where your proposed works listed above are located. All eight of these locations are within the Hutton Rudby Conservation Area, the character and appearance of which would be adversely affected if this proposal were to go ahead.

It is noted that:

  • on Tuesday 22nd September workmen acting on behalf of BT Openreach drove five wooden stakes into the ground, breaking the surface of the registered Village Green at locations listed above and attached notices with reference number H0J-V22001;
  • on Thursday 24th September workmen drove a further three stakes into the ground, breaking the surface of the registered Village Green at the locations listed above and attached notices with reference number H0J-V9040; and
  • no prior contact had been made with Rudby Parish Council by Openreach or by its representatives to seek permission to install the stakes and notices on our land or to seek a wayleave agreement for your proposed works.

Content of the Openreach notices

The notices state that Openreach is “intending to notify [Planning Authority] that it is intending to install a pole(s) pursuant to the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 2016 (amended) (England) and the Electronic Communications Code (conditions and restrictions) Regulations 2003 (as amended)”.

Under prior notification procedures, as a statutory consultee we would expect to be invited to comment by the Planning Authority shortly after they have received and validated your notification.  We have not received any such invitation from North Yorkshire Council, and a prior notice for your proposed work is not yet showing on the planning portal of your notification.

Please clarify whether and when you notified North Yorkshire Council.

Consequences of wilful harm to a Village Green

Registered Village Greens are subject to various statutory protections arising from the Inclosure Act 1857, the Commons Act 1876 and other subsequent legislation.   The Village Green is not part of an adopted highway.  Rights which Openreach may have in relation to highways and associated verges do not apply to any part of the Village Green. Wilfully causing harm to a Village Green is a summary offence under the Inclosure Act. The Parish Council’s opinion is that implementing the proposed works would be an act of wilful harm.

Please be advised that no works of any kind may be performed by Openreach on the Village Green without the express written permission of Rudby Parish Council.  Our permission is required for any activity which breaks the surface of the ground including but not limited to installation of stakes to hold notices and to the proposed installation of poles.  It is further noted that rights available to the Parish Council under the Inclosure Act include the removal and sale of any such material installed without authorisation.

Street Works Rights do not apply to this proposal.

Part 8, Schedule 3A to the Communications Act 2003 deals with CONFERRAL OF STREET WORK RIGHTS AND THEIR EXERCISE

Paragraph 57 gives the definition of street:

 “street” means a street in England and Wales which is a maintainable highway (within the meaning of Part 3 of New Roads and Street Works Act 1991)

Paragraph 58 sets out the right which provide powers enabling the installation of poles on a street

(1) For the purposes of this code a “street work right”, in relation to an operator, is—

(a) a right to install and keep electronic communications apparatus in, on, under, over, along or across a street or a road;

The Village Green is not a maintainable highway which means it is not a street as defined in paragraph 57, therefore, paragraph 58 is not engaged.  Consequently, the proposed works cannot be performed under street works rights conferred on operators by the Communications Act 2003.

Code Rights do not apply without the site occupier’s agreement

Paragraph 9, Part 2, Schedule 3A to the Communications Act 2003 (the Electronic Communications Code, as inserted by the Digital Economy Act 2017) states:

“A code right in respect of land may only be conferred on an operator by an agreement between the occupier of the land and the operator.”

Within the meaning of the Communications Act, Rudby Parish Council is the occupier of the land on which Openreach proposes to install poles.  No wayleave between Openreach and Rudby Parish Council for the proposed works exists or has been requested.  No order has been issued by the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) to impose an agreement.  Furthermore, Rudby Parish Council has not been notified of any application to the Tribunal.

As no agreement exists, Openreach currently has no Code Rights for the proposed works.

Rudby Parish Council advises Openreach that another Operator (Quickline) recently installed fibre to the premises (FTTP) infrastructure in the same area using underground cabling only.  A very small part of that work required access to the Village Green and the contractors acting on behalf of Quickline followed the correct process of seeking consent in advance for the work from Rudby Parish Council. It is very disappointing that Openreach has not done likewise.

We also note that on 12 October 2026 Openreach appeared to be installing underground cabling elsewhere in the village on Garbutts Lane / West End near the proposed location of these poles.  Rudby Parish Council is of the opinion that underground cabling is the most appropriate technical solution for this sensitive area of the Hutton Rudby Conservation Area.

Rudby Parish Council’s opinion is that the technical feasibility and economic viability of underground installation cannot reasonably be in doubt because Quickline have recently installed service lines underground in the same area and throughout the village, and Openreach are also installing underground cabling elsewhere in the village.

It is Rudby Parish Council’s understanding that there is an expectation, but not an obligation, for service providers to share ducting where feasible. Given the sensitive nature of the proposed location, it would seem reasonable to expect that this option would be thoroughly investigated by Openreach before a proposal to install overhead lines was brought forward.

Rudby Parish Council would like to know whether any such discussions have taken place, what the outcome of those discussions was, and why underground cabling is not being proposed.

Permitted Development Rights rely on Code Rights or control of land

The Openreach notices state an intention to use the General Permitted Development Order (GPDO) to obtain planning consent.   Rudby Parish Council understands the proposed mechanism would be Part 16 Class A which defines Permitted Development as:

A. Development by or on behalf of an electronic communications code operator for the purpose of the operator’s electronic communications network in, on, over or under land controlled by that operator or in accordance with the electronic communications code, consisting of—

(a) the installation, alteration or replacement of any electronic communications apparatus,

Class A is only engaged when a development proposal meets one of two tests: 1) it relates to “land controlled by that operator”; or 2) the proposal is “in accordance with the electronic communications code”. 

Openreach does not own, lease or have a wayleave for the land on which it proposes the development. Hence, the land cannot in any sense be deemed as “land controlled by that operator”.  The first test fails.

For the reasons set out in more detail above, the proposed locations are not on streets and there is no wayleave, hence neither Code Rights nor Street Works Rights apply to the proposed development.  The proposed development is, therefore, not “in accordance with the electronic communications code”, hence the second test also fails.

Planning consent cannot be obtained under Part 16, Class A unless and until Openreach either acquire a Code Right or control of the land neither of which they currently have.  

Rudby Parish Council acknowledges that a full planning application could be submitted by Openreach, but doing so would first require that Openreach serves notice on Rudby Parish Council as the landowner.  We have received no such notice.

Summary

This letter focuses on issues related to Code Rights, Street Works Rights, land ownership and occupation, and planning procedures.  For the reasons set out above, it is our opinion that the Openreach Proposal is fundamentally flawed on both a procedural and legal basis.  Even if planning consent could be obtained by GPDO, it is our opinion that Openreach currently has no lawful basis to carry out the proposed installation.

We will address our grounds of objection in terms of material planning considerations separately.  In broad terms these relate to harms caused to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area and harms caused to the Village Green.

Rudby Parish Council requests that Openreach constructively engages with us so that a better way forward for this important infrastructure upgrade can be agreed and brought forward.

Rudby Parish Council requests that Openreach confirms in writing by 31st October 2026 that it will not commence any installation work until the issues raised in this letter have been resolved to our satisfaction.

Yours sincerely,

Hilary Cope

Clerk to Rudby Parish Council